Hey, before you read further: If you haven’t already, please consider supporting the work of Balls & Strikes by subscribing here. It helps the site a lot, and I would be very grateful. Okay, back to our regularly scheduled programming (Trump lawyers humiliating themselves in public).
Earlier this year, the administration announced its intent to renovate the century-old East Potomac Golf Course, which is located on federally owned land just south of the Jefferson Memorial in Washington, D.C. The East Potomac complex’s three courses—Red, White, and Blue, naturally—are both inexpensive to play and open to the public, which, as Alex Kirschner writes at Slate, are not things that Donald Trump believes golf should be. Thus, Trump wants to cancel the lease of the National Links Trust, the nonprofit organization that manages the three existing courses, and replace them with a “championship”-caliber course at an estimated cost of somewhere between $20 million and $49 million.
The National Links Trust quickly filed a lawsuit in federal district court, but for several months, the Trump administration essentially shrugged its shoulders at every hearing, explaining to the presiding judge, Biden appointee Ana Reyes, that officials were still considering their options and did not intend to break ground on anything anytime soon. And at first, Reyes gave the government the benefit of the doubt, explaining that she did not want to “assume that the agency is going to act in bad faith before they have acted.”
In news that will probably not surprise you, there is evidence to suggest that the Trump administration was not telling Reyes the whole truth. On October 10, crews cut down and removed hundreds of trees from the site—ostensibly for maintenance, and definitely not as a precursor to the multimillion-dollar renovation plan that the construction-obsessed president had already announced. On October 18, Trump said on Truth Social that the course would close on November 15; the next day, he further accelerated the process, announcing that the project did not require “approval,” and that work would begin “IMMEDIATELY!”
In more news that will probably not surprise you, Reyes did not care for any of these developments. In a hearing on October 12, she described herself as “thoroughly unamused,” ordered the government to provide at least 72 hours’ notice before doing anything else to alter the course, and threatened to initiate contempt proceedings if the government violated the order by “two seconds.” Reyes also told Justice Department lawyers that they had “lost credibility” with her; when they tried to assure her that they had done their “best” to keep her apprised, she responded, “No, you did not do your best. You did your absolute worst.”
A week later, when Trump announced the course’s closure, an even more exasperated Reyes held another hearing, essentially asking how Justice Department lawyers could assert that no construction was imminent when Trump was blasting out all-caps proclamations that work would begin “IMMEDIATELY!” On October 26, she barred the Trump administration from removing any more trees and extended the notice requirement from 72 hours to ten business days. Reyes also took the chance to air out the government lawyers with whom she’d been so patient: “Rarely, if ever, has the United States Department of Justice urged a federal court not to believe the sitting President,” she wrote.
Given that Reyes is (1) a lady, (2) associated with Joe Biden, and (3) telling him what to do, Trump reacted to all of this by losing his goddamn mind. His lawyers at the DOJ tried and failed to get her removed from the case in light of her “animosity for the Trump Administration,” which as far as I can tell just refers to the fact that she issued a decision he did not like. After Trump posted on Truth Social that Reyes “may be insane,” Reyes and her family received death threats. Eventually, The Washington Post ran a story titled “5 things to know about the federal judge Trump called a ‘crazed lunatic’,” which is not the sort of headline that a major newspaper runs when democracy is, to use a technical term, in a good place.
In a follow-up post on Monday, Trump continued to complain about the terms of Reyes’s injunction, arguing that it is not “fair” or “Constitutional” to require the government to answer to “a judge who has no expertise in Golf, Architecture, Landscaping, [or] Construction.” It has been some time since I took constitutional law, but I am reasonably sure that if there were a provision that required Article III judges to be familiar with principles of water hazard placement before telling government lawyers to stop lying to her face, I would remember it.
In the context of all the other cartoonishly illegal and/or grossly incompetent stunts that Trump lawyers have tried to pull over the last 21 months, I concede that playing fast and loose with a golf course renovation might not feel especially consequential. But as the buzzer sounds on the first half of Trump’s second term, his decision to go to war over a tacky golf course renovation is a pretty clean illustration of how quickly the Department of Justice has turned into a government-subsidized employment program for oafish reactionaries who cannot keep their stories straight. Reyes is the latest addition to the ranks of federal judges who are tired not only of Trump’s bullshit, but also of the lawyers who keep making excuses for it.
If you enjoyed this post, please consider supporting the work of Balls & Strikes with a monthly or annual subscription. Click here to learn more and sign up.
You can find everything we publish by visiting ballsandstrikes.org, and by following us on Bluesky at @ballsandstrikes.org. You can get in touch by emailing us at contact@ballsandstrikes.org. Thanks for reading.
This Week In Balls & Strikes
Right-Wing Lawyers Keep Pushing a Constitutional Right to Discriminate Against LGBTQ People, Madiba Dennie
This six-justice conservative supermajority keeps telling conservative activists exactly what kinds of cases to bring next.
This Might Be the Trump DOJ’s Stupidest Legal Argument Yet, Jay Willis
Trump’s lawyers are now rewriting federal statutes and hoping that judges won’t notice.
House Republicans: Judges Who Rule Against Trump Must Be Punished Swiftly and Harshly, Madiba Dennie
Nothing is more important for GOP lawmakers than soothing their boss’s wounded ego.
This Week In Other Stuff We Appreciated
These Are the Big Midterm Elections Flying Under the Radar, Daniel Nichanian and Lauren Dominguez Chan, The New York Times
“I find state courts to be the sleeper level of government when it comes to abortion access. Judges have issued a string of rulings around the country on abortion, and many of the justices who’ve taken part in these rulings are on the ballot in November — in 10 states, by my count.”
Several States Made It a Crime to Talk About Abortion. Will Courts Now Enforce It?, Mary Ziegler, Slate
“That’s one of the reasons that attacks on abortion-related speech are gaining steam: Conservatives recognize that it may be more effective to attack shield laws by policing the information available to abortion-seekers.”




Ana Reyes is also (4) Hispanic.
Judges have police power, it would be nice to see one of them - just one of them - use it when confronted with DOJ attorneys that knowingly ignore their orders.